NERCHE

The American college campus as a built form, read in New England.

Types

The Dormitory

Rooms in staircases or rooms off a corridor is the oldest argument in collegiate housing, and each answer produces a different building and a different social life.

TypesMedium entryFour programmes that hardened into rules.

A staircase hall inside a college dormitory, worn stone treads, numbered doors opening off each landing, daylight from a high window
Rooms in staircases or rooms off a corridor is the oldest argument in collegiate housing, and each answer produces a different building and a different social life.

From staircase to corridor, the plan decides who meets whom

The room that a student sleeps in is, architecturally, almost the smallest decision a college makes. The building that holds those rooms is among the largest — in cost, in mass, in the daily life it organises without anyone noticing it is doing so.

Two plans have competed on New England campuses since the seventeenth century. In the first, a common stair rises from a shared entry and gives onto a handful of rooms on each landing; students on that stair form a unit whether they intend to or not. In the second, a single corridor runs the length of the building and rooms open off it on one or both sides; everyone passes everyone else, or no one does, depending on the hour. The stair plan produces small, overlapping clusters. The corridor plan produces an institution.

A stone college chapel with a square tower standing at the end of an axis, collegiate buildings framing it on both sides, overcast daylight
The chapel — The chapel held the centre of the plan long after compulsory attendance ended, which is why so many campuses still point at one.

Harvard Yard, Cambridge, Massachusetts, settled the stair type early. Massachusetts Hall, completed in 1720, stacks its chambers on independent stairs, and the building's long brick facade — Flemish bond above a water table of rougher stone — gives no hint from outside that the interior is anything other than a single connected volume. It is not; it is four staircases wearing one coat. The type persisted through Hollis, Stoughton and the later Yard dormitories, and it persisted for a reason: it made a college of a building by forcing accidental society on the people it housed.

The corridor plan came in later and came in large. When colleges expanded fast — through the land-grant era, through the growth surges after both World Wars — they needed beds quickly and cheaply, and the double-loaded corridor (rooms on each side of a central hall) delivered them. A building ninety feet wide with rooms fourteen feet deep on each face is geometrically efficient and socially anonymous. Bowdoin College in Brunswick, Maine, and Dartmouth College in Hanover, New Hampshire, both accumulated dormitory blocks through the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries that follow exactly this logic, their brick masses sitting on open ground in the way that their predecessors never quite do.

The architecture followed the argument, but it also reinforced it. James Gamble Rogers, working at Yale University in New Haven, Connecticut through the 1920s and 1930s, wrapped both stair-entry planning and Collegiate Gothic masonry around courtyards in a deliberate effort to manufacture the social texture of an English residential college. The residential colleges Rogers built — Branford, Saybrook, Jonathan Edwards — are not single buildings in the dormitory sense at all; they are compounds, each with its own gate, its own dining hall and its own cluster of staircases arranged around a court. The choice of stair over corridor was inseparable from the choice of closed court over open ground, and both were inseparable from Edward Harkness's money and his conviction that Yale's undergraduate life needed something it had not yet built.

At the women's colleges the problem was arranged differently from the start. Mount Holyoke College in South Hadley, Massachusetts grew from Mary Lyon's original seminary building of 1837, in which every function — sleeping, eating, studying, worshipping — was held under one roof precisely because the building was also the institution. As Mount Holyoke expanded across the nineteenth century, the dormitory separated out from the classroom and the chapel but kept, in many of its buildings, a domestic scale that the men's-college corridor block never achieved. Smith College in Northampton, Massachusetts took the idea further: its residential houses are literally domestic in scale, borrowed from the surrounding neighborhood's architecture, and the corridor plan appears almost nowhere. Students live in houses, not in buildings called dormitories.

Cope & Stewardson, before their manner reached New Haven, showed at Bryn Mawr College in Bryn Mawr, Pennsylvania that the stair plan and the Gothic arch could be made to work together structurally and socially in ways the corridor plan never permitted. Their Pembroke Hall of 1894 uses an arcade at ground level to give the staircases a communal threshold — covered, shared, collegiate — before a student even reaches her own entry.

1720Massachusetts Hall
1894Pembroke Hall
1920sRogers's residential colleges at Yale

The argument has never quite ended. Contemporary residence halls oscillate between the two types, sometimes stacking cluster-suites to approximate the stair plan within a building whose fire stairs and egress requirements belong entirely to the corridor tradition. The plan decides who meets whom. The building is the decision, made in brick and held for a century.

Plan types to diagram
  • Stair-entry plan— each stair gives access to a handful of rooms per floor; entries are independent or loosely connected
  • Single-loaded corridor— rooms on one side only, glazed on the other; more light, less efficient
  • Double-loaded corridor— rooms on both sides of a central hall; maximum beds per floor, minimum natural light to the corridor itself
  • Cluster suite— a corridor plan that groups rooms around shared lounges to simulate stair-type sociability

Harvard Yard, Cambridge, Massachusetts, settled the stair type early.

Chronology of the type
  1. 1720Massachusetts Hall, Harvard Yard; stair-entry plan in early Georgian brick
  2. 1894Pembroke Hall, Bryn Mawr; Cope & Stewardson; Gothic arcade unifying independent stair entries
  3. 1920s–30sRogers's residential colleges at Yale; stair entries organised around closed courts with shared dining
Long oak library tables under tall windows, individual lamps, a very high plastered ceiling, adults reading
The reading room — Long tables, high side light and a ceiling far above anyone using it — the type settled early and has barely moved.